Publisher’s description for The Bookshop of Second Chances by Jackie Fraser:

Set in a charming little Scottish town, The Bookshop of Second Chances is an uplifting story of fresh starts and new beginnings by a hugely talented debut author.

Thea’s having a bad month. Not only has she been made redundant, she’s also discovered her husband of nearly twenty years is sleeping with one of her friends. And he’s not sorry – he’s leaving.

Bewildered and lost, Thea doesn’t know what to do. But, when she learns the great-uncle she barely knew has died and left her his huge collection of second-hand books and a house in the Scottish Lowlands, she seems to have been offered a second chance.

Running away to a little town where no one knows her seems like exactly what Thea needs. But when she meets the aristocratic Maltravers brothers – grumpy bookshop owner Edward and his estranged brother Charles, Lord Hollinshaw – her new life quickly becomes just as complicated as the life she was running from...

*******************************

3/5 stars

What happens when Evvie Drake lands in a Jenny Colgan novel? This book. A recently divorced middle-aged woman finds herself in a tiny Scotland town where she has inherited a house and starts working in a bookshop. It was a cozy read I devoured in a few days. I love sinking in to a small town British setting like this book has. On paper it has everything I like in a book!

But I had a couple of fairly major issues with it that ultimately bring down the rating. First, everything happens far too fast in the first chapter. The pacing was off. Come to find out, the first chapter was submitted to publishers as part of a contest, and once I knew that it made perfect sense. That uneven feeling carried through the book. I wanted more emotion and background about the main character's relationship with her ex-husband, more about her sorting through her feelings rather than brushing them off. Her response to his cheating and suddenly dumping her after decades largely comes across as 'Eh, I wasn't happy about it but I didn't want to be a jerk to him.' ?!?! And then, finally, and the reason I can't give this more than three stars even though there was a lot of it I enjoyed, is that the reader is asked to not only overlook abusive and discriminatory behavior from a character who literally forbids women working for him, but to ultimately somehow find it charming and fall in love with him a little. I am very over giving hateful men a pass. We can understand the reasons for this behavior without condoning it or needing it in our life. And the thing is, at times he was very charming and I did like him! So this aspect of his character just seemed like an unnecessary plot device.

All of which is to say, I read fast because I like the setting and the concept and I couldn’t figure out how I felt about the book. Ultimately, the character development was uneven and at times frustrating, and I ended the book with a lot of questions and some irritation. I think with sharper editing, tightened pacing, and cutting out some of the unnecessary extreme behavior, this book could be great.

Thank you, NetGalley and Random House Ballantine for the ARC!